Common Misconceptions About Forensic Animations

There seems to be many preconceived notions about forensic animations and their overall use in litigation. Many times, lawyers or accident reconstructionists will say that “An animation can show whatever the animator wants” or “Animations are difficult to admit in a court of law”. However, to a forensic animator, this is also like saying, that your accountant can “fix your books”. In reality, it is far from the truth.

Misconception #1 – “An animation can show whatever the animator wants”
Perhaps it is the fact that so much of what we see on television and in films is altered with lifelike special effects that we tend to associate anything with 3D visualization with more than a hint of skepticism. Ironically, much of the same software used to animate films such as “Spiderman” or “Lord of the rings” is also less known to be used in scientific visualization, research and forensic animations. People may associate the fact that an experienced special effects animator is capable of creating surreal, yet realistic looking effects. Therefore, it must not be accurate.

The greatest difference between a forensic animation and just any other type of animation is the “forensic” part. This implies that there is a large effort in understanding the details of what is being animated and that there is a large emphasis ensuring a high level of accuracy. An animator can spend more than 70% of his time on activities related to the verification of data and ensuring accuracy in the animation.

An experienced and qualified forensic animator would tell you that a large effort goes into building and checking each step of the animation process to the correct and accurate dimensions. In fact, very little is left to the imagination since most recreations are based on accurate data typically provided by the expert witness. A simple example is the terrain data of a particular scene. This can be obtained by means of a total station along with the positions of important features such as signs, traffic lights, debris or tire marks on the roadway.

Even the animation and motion of objects in a 3D recreation is typically based on information or data provided by the expert witness. This data is often obtained through careful calculations or through the use of simulation software. In the case of simulation software, the data can be directly converted or imported directly into the 3D animation software, leaving little room for error.
There may be cases where the forensic animator is provided with less than ideal information, however, even in these rare instances, an experienced forensic animator will have enough knowledge to ensure that the basic rules of geometry and physics (i.e. motion) are applied and adhered to.

Misconception #2 – “Animations are difficult to admit in a court of law”
Somewhere along the way, there have been animations which were so poorly constructed or erroneous they simply could not have been allowed in court. It would seem that these cases tend to stick in the minds of litigators and cause reluctance for future use of what is a perfectly acceptable and effective use of technology.

Normally, it is an inexperienced animator or lawyer which does not follow some of the basic rules of demonstrative evidence.
Some key points to consider when considering a forensic animation are:

1. The animation needs to support the testimony of the expert witness and should be considered an extension of the witness’ report. The expert witness should be directly involved in authenticating and reviewing the animation.

2. Disclose the animation well in advance of the trial date. Evidence needs to be disclosed in a timely manner and the opponent requires time to cross examine the evidence.

3. The animation fairly and accurately conveys the data or matter that it purports to convey or depict. The animation should not be prejudicial in that it outweighs the probative value.

4. The animation should be relevant.

5. The forensic animator should be prepared to testify that the works created are based on sound technology, process and algorithms such that the final works are a reflection of the expert witness’ opinion.

There are, of course, many other factors to consider which may be case dependent. Further materials and references are available for review including a paper entitled “The Admissibility of Demonstrative Evidence in Jury Trials:” Written by Barbara Legate of Legate and Associates and available at the AI2 forums (www.ai2-3d.com/Forums).

Today, most forensic animations are admitted into court since there are greater considerations and groundwork taken into account to ensure the accuracy, validity and quality of the animations. By choosing an experienced forensic animator and by adhering to the rules of demonstrative evidence, the risks associated with inadmissibility are greatly reduced.

Misconception #3 – “Animation and Simulation are the same thing”
There are two distinct ways to develop an animation and although the end result may try to achieve the same thing, they are fundamentally different in the means by which they are created.

A simulation is typically the output of a program which is operated by a qualified accident reconstructionist. The program has a set of key behaviours (i.e. mathematical equations) which define the movement of objects when given a set of known parameters. It is up to the accident reconstructionist to define all the input variables and ensure they are accurate. Once this is complete, the program is initiated to calculate all the positions of objects through some specific time.

The simulation software may also output the motion of objects in the form of exportable tabularized data and/or animation. However, most manufacturers of simulation based software programs have not been able to achieve the same level of realism as most animators are able to do with 3D visualization software. There may be a number of reasons to this which deal with further complicating already complex software or that perhaps the time spent on development is in the mathematics behind the simulation software and not primarily in the visualization or presentation of the data.

Another important issue which is common with simulation software is the validity of the data available. The old saying “garbage in, garbage out” is applicable. Since a simulation would typically be used as substantive evidence, it can get difficult to prove something is accurate without having solid data to back the animation up.

Animation
Demonstrative Evidence – illustrates how something works or how something happened based on the testimony of the expert or eye witness. The animator, not the software is responsible for accurately moving and positioning objects over time.
Does not try to prove anything, but just facilitates the account or testimony of a witness.

Simulation
Substantive Evidence – Takes actual dynamics and physics into account. The objects are not animated by “hand”, but by software based on calculated inputs or data.
Tries to prove that something may have occurred a certain way.
Visually, an animation is more eye catching and realistic.
Simulations are improving in their presentation, but are still lacking realism.

On the other hand, an animation may be based on an eye witness testimony, calculations of the accident reconstructionist or from data output by a simulation package. All the events of an animation in a typical 3D visualization package are calculated and setup by the animator. Animations are almost always disclosed as demonstrative evidence and they do not try to “prove” anything. They are merely another form of expressing the opinion of the expert witness and are always presented as demonstrative evidence.

Misconception #4 – “We need it yesterday”.
There have been many advances in the technology that forensic animators use which has improved the speed and efficiency of their work. Computer processing speeds have grown exponentially and the advances in software have allowed animators to do things which were simply not possible several years ago. There are even tools provided to animators which allow them to write custom scripts for repetitive tasks and specialized functions.
These advances in speed and ability would make one think that the time to complete an animation should also have been greatly reduced; however, this is not the case.

Part of this reason is simply the nature of the animation process. Much work needs to go into the understanding of the case, reading reports, taking measurements and verifying accuracy. This part alone can take a large part of the man-hours to create the animation.
Also, creating the 3D models (“scene assets”) necessary to populate the animation is still a time consuming process. There are some advantages when a “library” of standard models is used (i.e. stop signs, light poles, traffic signs), however since each case is different and the specific details need to be reflected in the animation (such as the scene topography or specific damage to the vehicle), time must be spent to customize or create models from scratch.

, ,

0 thoughts on “Common Misconceptions About Forensic Animations

  1. BruceTus says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Real-time, context-aware protection against ransomware wrapped in a user-friendly interface, featuring alerts and advanced tools

    Press the “Download Now” button to download AppCheck serial code.
    The whole process will just take a few moments.

    Mirror Link —> AppCheck crack exe

    – Version: 2.5.22.1
    – Company: CheckMAL Inc.
    – Downloads: 156
    – Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    – Status file: clean (as of last analysis)
    – File size: na
    – Price: 0
    – Special requirements: no
    – Home page: checkmal.com/page/product/appcheck/?lang=en
    – Rating:

    Tags:
    AppCheck crack keygen serial
    AppCheck crack latest
    AppCheck Crack Serial
    AppCheck license crack
    AppCheck crack hack

    More software:
    SmartSHOW 3D Full Version With Keys Latest
    DmitriRender With License Key Latest
    iMyFone iOS System Recovery Cracked
    AppCheck Crack Serial
    Renee Video Editor crack windows
    уникальность текста программа скачать
    Detroit Annexation 1806-1926 |
    download google books free
    xvideos video downloader
    Meble Plock, zaslony, firany, porcelana, prezenty slubne
    ГДЗ – готовые домашние задания и решебники

  2. BruceTus says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Press the “Download Now” button to download DOS2USB Cracked.
    The whole process will just take a few moments.

    Mirror Link —> DOS2USB Crack

    Automatically redirect your DOS Printer output to your USB printer with the help of this easy to use and configure software solution

    · Build: 2.30
    · Developer: Bhaktee Software
    · Downloads: 1924
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · Status file: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: na
    · Price: 0
    · Special requirements: no
    · User rating:

    Keywords:
    dos2usb crack only, dos2usb cracked full, dos2usb keygen crack, dos2usb serial keys x86/x64, dos2usb serial code, dos2usb license code, dos2usb cracked, dos2usb serial key, dos2usb full crack latest, dos2usb how to ctack

    Popular software:
    Focusky Crack Latest Version
    Outlook Recovery ToolBox crack exe
    Pingendo Keygen Crack
    повышение уникальности текста
    Andrew G. Legal – Offering cutting edge technologies to help reduce the cost of legal services.
    Download Rise of Nations: Thrones & Patriots crack version
    download google books
    youtu.be video downloader
    My First Blog Post!
    ГДЗ за 1-11 класс
    Software Cracks Keygens
    Repair missing or corrupt adbepm.dll

  3. BruceTus says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Press the “Download Now” button to download Bitwar Data Recovery Cracked.
    The whole process will just take a few moments.

    Mirror Link —> Bitwar Data Recovery full crack

    Recover inaccessible files from your your hard disk or a memory card with the help of this app that comes with a deep scan mode as well as multiple filters to easily uncover relevant data

    · Build: 6.4.7
    · Developer: Bitwar.net
    · Downloads: 1032
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · Status file: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: undefined
    · Price: 0
    · Special requirements: no
    · Rating:

    Keywords:
    bitwar data recovery cracked latest, bitwar data recovery cracked latest, bitwar data recovery full version serial keys latest, bitwar data recovery license, bitwar data recovery crack only, bitwar data recovery keygen crack, bitwar data recovery crack patch, bitwar data recovery full version serial keys latest, bitwar data recovery full version with keys latest, bitwar data recovery cracked latest

    Other useful resources:
    Droid Transfer cracked full
    Clone Files Checker Full Crack
    DraftSight with crack
    Антиплагиат повышение оригинальности онлайн
    Fotos Fashion | Luis Sanchez Photo
    Download Myth II: Soulblighter crack and keygen free download
    tool for downloading Google books
    download video from pornhub
    WANNAN RAYUWA! – DAKE AKE GLOBAL CONSULTANCY
    ГДЗ за 1-11 класс
    Software Cracks Keygens
    How to repair missing or corrupt oo2core_4_win64.dll

  4. BruceTus says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Click the “Download Now” button to download Fast Video Downloader Crack.
    The whole process will just take a few seconds.

    A lightweight and straightforward application that allows you to download your favorite videos from several online hosting websites

    Mirror Link —> Fast Video Downloader patch

    · Version: 3.1.0.31
    · Build date: June 18 2019
    · Developer: FastPcTools
    · Downloads: 19506
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: unknown
    · Price: gratis
    · Special requirements: no
    · Systems: Win 10 64 bit / Win 10 / Win 2003 / Win 8 64 bit / Win 8 / Win 7 64 bit / Win 7 / Win Vista 64 bit / Win Vista / Win XP
    · Rating:

    Keywords:
    fast video downloader serial code, fast video downloader license crack, fast video downloader keygen crack, fast video downloader crack install, fast video downloader full crack latest, fast video downloader keygen crack, fast video downloader keygen serial, fast video downloader crack, fast video downloader crack patch, fast video downloader keygen crack patch

    More software: this way

  5. BruceTus says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Press the “Download Now” button to download AB Bulk Mailer activator.
    The whole process will just take a few moments.

    Easy-to-learn app that sends emails in bulk mode, featuring numerous useful options, including a task scheduler and a contacts manager

    Mirror Link —> AB Bulk Mailer Cracked Latest

    · Version: 9.8.1
    · Build date: Nov 12th 2018
    · Company: Advanced Business Objects
    · Downloads: 8022
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: unknown
    · Price: 0
    · Special requirements: no requirements
    · Systems: Windows 10 64 bit, Windows 10, Windows 8 64 bit, Windows 8, Windows 7 64 bit, Windows 7, Windows Vista 64 bit, Windows Vista, Windows XP, Windows 2K
    · Rating:

    Tags cloud:
    ab bulk mailer cracked latest, ab bulk mailer crack fix, ab bulk mailer full crack, ab bulk mailer keygen serial, ab bulk mailer keygen crack, ab bulk mailer serial number, ab bulk mailer serial number, ab bulk mailer activate code, ab bulk mailer crack install, ab bulk mailer crack keygen serial

    Popular software: this way

  6. BruceTus says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Click the “Download Now” button to download Smarter Battery Cracked.
    The process will just take a few moments.

    Monitor the battery status of your laptop, perform calibration operations and place a small battery gadget on your screen with this user-friendly tool

    Mirror —> https://crack4download.com/crack?s=Smarter-Battery&id=96073

    · Release version: 5.7
    · Build date: March 15th 2019
    · Company: Microsys Com Ltd
    · Downloads: 25404
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: unknown
    · Price: no cost
    · Special requirements: no
    · Systems: Win 10 64 bit / Win 10 / Win 8 64 bit / Win 8 / Win 7 64 bit / Win 7 / Win Vista 64 bit / Win Vista / Win XP
    · User rating:

    Keywords:
    smarter battery keygen crack, smarter battery crack hack, smarter battery keygen serial, smarter battery with license key latest, smarter battery crack windows, smarter battery crack new, smarter battery cracked, smarter battery crack patch, smarter battery crack latest version, smarter battery cracked latest

    More software keygens: https://crack4download.com

    More software:
    Mickey Reise – Small Girl Problems | xxxpornmikelenaisus
    Антиплагиат повышение оригинальности бесплатно
    Industry news – XpertIT
    Download Championship Surfer cracked
    Жизнь без нафтизина — Я дышу! или Как избавиться от нафтизиновой зависимости
    Turn Windows 10 quickly
    Скачать Comodo Dragon серийный ключ и кряк
    ГДЗ для школы
    Repair missing or corrupt mfco42d.dll

  7. BruceTus says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Push the “Download Now” button to download Cocosenor Windows Password Tuner Ultimate with crack.
    The whole process will just take a few moments.

    Reset your local or Microsoft account passwords quickly and efficiently by relying on this specialized app that helps you generate a reset disk

    Mirror —> Cocosenor Windows Password Tuner Ultimate serial number

    · Version: 3.2.0
    · Patch date: Jun 14th 2018
    · Developer: Cocosenor
    · Downloads: 3802
    · Download type: safety (no torrent/no viruses)
    · File status: clean (as of last analysis)
    · File size: unknown
    · Price: gratis
    · Special requirements: no
    · Systems: Windows NT, Windows Server 2016, Windows 10 64 bit, Windows 10, Windows Server 2012, Windows 2008 R2, Windows 2008 64 bit, Windows 2008, Windows 2003, Windows 8 64 bit, Windows 8, Windows 7 64 bit, Windows 7, Windows Vista 64 bit, Windows Vista, Windows XP 64 bit, Windows XP, Windows 2K
    · Rating:

    Keywords:
    cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate full version serial keys latest, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate crack serial number, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate full crack latest, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate full version serial keys latest, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate crack hack, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate cracked, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate keygen free download, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate with license key latest, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate keygen crack, cocosenor windows password tuner ultimate + crack latest

    More software keygens: here

    Other useful resources:
    Scaup |
    как повысить уникальность текста в антиплагиате
    Vamonos a Mexico – Aaron and Jackie Mosley
    Download Brass Tactics keygen crack patch
    New adventure: BranchCreation – Software Development
    How to Turn Off Windows Defender
    Скачать Mac Media Player серийный ключ и кряк
    Download msvcp110_win.dll to fix missing or corrupted DLL errors
    Ремонт микроволновой печи | Ремонт Микроволновых, DVD, LCD, ЖК телевизоров своими руками.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *